Strayer Univeristy Week 6 Quantitative Evaluation Discussion
Description
Week 6 Discussion
Quantitative Evaluation
Field experiments have been used to test the effectiveness of policy “nudges”—attempts by government to align desirable social behavior with individual incentives in policy areas ranging from retirement planning to tax compliance. Both the Democratic administration of President Obama and the Conservative government of David Cameron in the U.K. have supported this type of research. For your Discussion this week, choose one of the two scenarios provided and complete the corresponding prompts.
Scenario 1: Affordable Care Act
Assume that the Affordable Care Act (ACA), a landmark healthcare reform act passed by the United States Government in 2012, is still in the process of full implementation. Prior to its passage, earlier versions originally proposed the provision of medical care free of charge to the U.S. population. Suppose that you have been asked to evaluate the potential effects of the ACA nationwide. There are two key issues to consider. One issue has to do with how much more medical care people would use if it could be offered free of charge. The second issue has to do with what effect the medical care would have on the health of the average person. Assume you have 3–5 years to conduct the evaluation.
Post by Day 3 a response to the following:
- Assuming no financial restraint, briefly outline what method(s) you would suggest using for assessing the impact of free coverage on usage of medical services and on health outcomes. Use a randomized field experimental design, a cost benefit/effectiveness quantitative evaluation design, or both, and explain your choice.
Respond by Day 5 to two colleagues in the following way:
- Explain the adequacy of the design your colleague has selected to use and how you might improve it or employ a different design approach. Explain how your colleagues’ design approach addresses the internal validity issue.
Scenario 2: Nudging
Post by Day 3 a response to the following:
- Briefly describe a nudging field experiment design focused on encouraging more self-employed taxpayers to file their estimated taxes. Consider both coercive and nudge style mechanisms to accomplish this, with an aim to demonstrate the effectiveness of the methods.
Respond by Day 5 to two colleagues in the following way:
- Explain what other incentives you might think of to make the nudge more effective and why you might use them.
Note: Within the Week 6 Forum, use the appropriate thread for your selected scenario:
- For Scenario 1, use the “Week 6 Discussion – Scenario 1” thread.
- For Scenario 2, use the “Week 6 Discussion – Scenario 2” thread.
